Here are the communications that occurred between me and the Catholic girl I mentioned in a previous post (CCG stands for Crazy Catholic Girl). I already posted the most humorous parts, but here is the rest:
CCG:I hate sharing my feelings, but this is important.
This final year in school has been very important and
I didn't want any distractions. I needed to be
completely focused on school. I want to know why,
after your last email in July, you didn't try to call
or email me once. I didn't respond because I needed
this year to learn about myself and to work some
things out. I did have feelings for you but I'm not
sure if I still do. I'm uncomfortable and I get
nervous talking to you. It seems like we both have
changed so much and we're further apart than ever.
Ever since I met you, we have been going back and
forth from talking for awhile to having no
communication for awhile. I feel like I have always
been the one to reconnect. There were times when I
wondered what you were up to, so I contacted you. It
seems like too much of a hassle to keep doing this.
I'm sorry.
(Please only respond to this by email.)
Me: First of all, I am impressed that you opened up and wrote down your feelings like this. This is a very courageous thing to do.
One of my worries was that you were attracted to me beyond friendship. If I understand your e-mail correctly (and please correct me if I'm wrong!), that is indeed the case. I admit I felt a bit nervous around you for this reason (not that feeling this way about a person is a bad or terrible thing… believe me, I have a number of friends that I'm half in love with). However, while I was working on my MA in Kansas, I was coming to grips with something you need to hear about now: I'm gay.
You are totally correct that we have changed. In high school, although I was aware of my sexuality, I was comfortable hiding it. I honestly believed that I could change the way I felt about other guys on my own, or with the assistance of a pastor or therapist. However, as time went by, and no progress was made, I accepted who I am. After I graduated from the University of Alberta, I came out of the closet to a small group of people. Since then, I've gradually become more comfortable with myself, and eased my way further out of the closet.
I hadn't written to you after that e-mail in July because I thought you didn't want to hear from me. I want to stay your friend, because you are a beautiful, giving, trustworthy person. However, in order for this to work, we need to accept that each of us has changed. You'll need to realize that I'm now a not-terribly-religious gay man, and I'll need to respect your faith.
Whatever the case, DON'T let this affect your school or personal life! Please write me or call me! I'd like to talk about this, if you're willing to.
CCG:
Thank you for telling me this. I'm relieved that I can
finally have some closure. However, as you might have
guessed, I'm in total shock. I can't even express
right now what I'm feeling, yet I have so many
thoughts and questions. (It's a good thing you told me
this by email instead of on the phone or in person. It
wouldn't have been a pretty sight.) I am going to need
some time to process all of this, I just don't know
how much time I will need. I don't know what else to
say. You've hurt me though.
Me:
Let me know if you want to talk about this. Contact me when you're ready.
CCG:
I think I'm ready to discuss the issue now. I think it
would be best if we just communicate by email for
right now. I have had a lot of time to think about
everything. I still have so many questions too. I
don't understand why you never said anything before.
How could you keep it from me all this time? I feel
lied to and betrayed. We've gone through so much
together. I thought I could trust you. How can I even
trust you now? You know I'm strongly against such a
lifestyle, and I am not going to accept it.
Ideally, I would like to still be friends. I care
about you and think about you everyday. It will be
difficult, if not impossible for me to not think about
your lifestyle. I wish I could get past it but it's
just always going to be there. I find that I think
about you as someone I once knew or as someone that
you're not.
I don't like how our friendship has always been off
and on. In my mind, friends talk maybe once a
week-over the phone or by email. I guess our
friendship is far different though. Maybe we should
just let the friendship go and move on. It hurts me to
be going through this.
Me:
I'm not sure why we can't communicate over the phone, but ok.
CCG, I'm not really sure I've done anything wrong here. It seems to me you're upset because you've invested a lot of emotion and time thinking about the two of us together. Give me an honest answer: were you hoping I was going to be interested in you beyond friendship?
Lied to and betrayed!? You never asked me if I was interested in women, nor did you ask me a single question about my dating history or anything along those lines! How can you suggest I lied to you or betrayed you? You didn't once express your feelings to me! What did you expect?
Once a week? Goodness, there are friends of mine I talk to once or twice a year! Distance makes communication difficult, despite our age of cell-phones and e-mail. I admit I haven't been particularly good (actually, I've been terrible) at keeping in touch. However, your expectations regarding communication are unreasonable. Also, I don't understand how you expect I wouldn't change over 7 years. Come on!!!
As far as my lifestyle is concerned, this should have nothing to do with our friendship. Friends stay together no matter what. As far as I can see you have two options here: you can accept who I am, and continue to stay in touch. I prefer this option. The other choice is that you continue to live in your dream world, thinking of me how you like... however, I'm not interested in staying in touch if this is your choice. I hate to be blunt, but this is emotionally taxing on me as well, my friend. If you can't handle things, then tough.
I want to hear your response. However, I'm giving you a week to reply. I'm sick and tired of getting these sporadic whiny e-mails, trying to make me feel horrible for something I can't control. If I don't hear from you by June 5th, I never want to hear from you again.